Unsolicited Advice from Mia Schachter

Unsolicited Advice from Mia Schachter

Share this post

Unsolicited Advice from Mia Schachter
Unsolicited Advice from Mia Schachter
I’m less of a “born this way” person and more of a “became this way” person.

I’m less of a “born this way” person and more of a “became this way” person.

Mia Schachter's avatar
Mia Schachter
Apr 09, 2025
∙ Paid
7

Share this post

Unsolicited Advice from Mia Schachter
Unsolicited Advice from Mia Schachter
I’m less of a “born this way” person and more of a “became this way” person.
3
2
Share

I put out an album! It’s the soundtrack to my musical, Squirm: A True Story, which I’ll be performing in June at Hollywood Fringe.

What would you like to ask a consent educator? Submit your questions here and I’ll answer them on this Substack.

My book, Unsolicited Advice: A Consent Educator's (Canceled) Memoir, starts here.

I have felt like an active participant in the building of my life and self, simultaneously creating and uncovering a self and a purpose. These two experiences—one being the making of the self and the other being the discovery of an essential self that was always there—may seem incompatible, and perhaps they are from a logical standpoint, and yet they coexist.

But when it comes to sexuality and gender, and even Lady Gaga, we repeatedly hear, “I was born this way.” That’s a totally legitimate experience and a totally legitimate narrative—I’m certainly not interested in trying to argue with anyone who feels aligned with it. It simply has not been mine.

Perhaps I was born with a proclivity towards fluidity, or a certain nebulousness, like my edges aren’t quite firm or fixed and easily mutable. That feels true to some degree. What also feels true is that I found and followed a particular line of questioning, and allowed myself to explore freely in the realm of sexuality and gender. I picked apart my behavior, preferences, and desires and interrogated the media and experiences that shaped them. I sought out the nuggets of self that were inherent, and examined the ones that were learned. Some I kept for my own, and some I tried to unlearn, to varying degrees of success. I found play at the bounds of gender roles and sexual orientation, reclaiming the now near-forbidden term ‘preference’ because I do in fact experience much of my sexual choices as preferences and, in fact, as choices. I prefer and I choose queer sex with other queer people. I prefer and I choose to embrace and indulge the parts of me that don’t feel like a woman, and play with gender like a set of paints or musical notes that change moment to moment, day to day, and over months or years, or even relative to who I’m with at any given time.

Live Classes • Recorded Classes • Workbooks • 1:1’s • Consulting • Merch! • Share the Load Podcast • You’re Doing It Wrong Podcast • Intimacy Coordination for TV, Film, + Theater

~ Just want access to this article? Venmo a donation to @sharetheload with your email address and the name of the article you want in the comment and I’ll send it to you ~

There’s a 10% off discount code to classes below the paywall…

Ana Mendieta

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to Unsolicited Advice from Mia Schachter to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Share the Load Inc.
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share